O Danny Boy

No snowflake ever falls
   in the wrong place. —Zen proverb

Bio  °  Blog  °  Contact  °  D School  °  Extras  °  Portfolio  °  Resumé

D SCHOOL BLOG ARCHIVES

An archived post from the 2004-05 school year.

 

Thursday, May 5, 2005

Design is in the Details

Finishing my thesis project prototype this week, it struck me that there's a significant blind spot in CMU's program (and from what I understand, other interaction design schools' programs as well): working with developers on a prototype to get the feel of the thing right. Because at school you very seldom get to the working prototype stage (due to time and money constraints), you don't ever get into the finesse of an interactive design, those tiny things that make a huge difference. And those tiny things can usually only be seen in a working thing that can be played with and broken and fiddled with. Animations and delays and such don't appear in flat paper prototypes and storyboards. At least not well.

CMU is supposedly better at building things than some other schools that have lots of cool ideas and slick videos to go with them, but it could be better. I suppose one could argue that this is what the thesis project is for: to take an idea out to the working prototype phase, but it seems like too important a thing to save until the very end of your graduate education. Especially considering that many people don't make it to the working prototype phase in their thesis work, or do projects that would be almost impossible to do that with without a team of developers.

Posted in CMU, Techniques, Thesis Project

 


Search Entries

 

Greatest Hits
A Definition of Design
Adaptive Worlds
Design Awareness
Ethics in Design
Ethnography and Models
Having an Experience
Participatory Design
Systems Design
What is an Art?
What is a Product?

 

2004-05 Categories
After School (6)
Alumni (3)
Assistantships (1)
Big Ideas (4)
CMU (12)
Classes (6)
Classmates (6)
Design 101 (4)
Extracurricular (9)
Meta (2)
Money (3)
Organizational Design (32)
Papers (1)
Programming (7)
Projects (14)
Reading (20)
Service Design (6)
Special Guest Stars (10)
Student Life (26)
Teaching (3)
Techniques (6)
Thesis Paper (13)
Thesis Project (10)
Typography (11)

 

2003-04 Categories
3D (2)
Alumni (8)
Assistantships (3)
Big Ideas (28)
Classes (20)
Classmates (26)
CMU (25)
Cognition (1)
CPID Program (4)
Design 101 (30)
Design Theory (21)
Extracurricular (15)
Faculty (13)
Field Trips (5)
HCI Program (4)
Info Design (3)
Interface Design (6)
Meta (8)
Money (8)
Papers (5)
Photography (5)
Preparation (6)
Projects (49)
Readings (33)
Software (8)
Special Guest Stars (15)
Student Life (21)
Teaching (3)
Techniques (12)
Thesis Paper (10)
Thesis Project (6)
Typography (9)
Visualization (8)

 

Coursework
Computing in Design
Design Seminar I
Design Seminar II
Design Studio I
Design Studio II
Graduate Typography
Interaction & Interface Design
Interactive Graphics
Mapping & Diagramming
Sketching & Modeling

 

Classmates and Alumni
Andy Cramer
Chad Thornton
Ben Fineman
Brian Haven
Elizabeth Windram
Jeong Kim
Hong Ha
Ian Hargraves
Jeff Howard
Kenneth Berger
Kerry Bodine
Kevin Fox
Mathilde Pignol
Micah Alpern
Neema Moraveji
Rob Adams

 

RSS Feeds
Excerpts
Full Entries

 

Subscribe
Want more spam? Sign up to receive this blog via email: